L. Marcuson 1852
H. Meyer 1852
A. Hermann 1858
Rev. Joseph Blumenthal 1858 – 1862
Rabbi James K. Gutheim 1863 – 1864
Rev. M. H. Meyers 1865
Rev. G. L. Rosenberger 1866 – 1869
Rabbi E. B. M. Browne 1869 – 1880
Rabbi Adolph Moses 1870 – 1873
Rabbi B. E. Jacobs 1873 – 1876
Rabbi Sigmund Hecht 1876 – 1888
Rabbi E. K. Fischer 1888 – 1892
Rabbi David Davidson 1892 – 1895
Rabbi Israel Joseph 1895 – 1896
Prof. Gotthard Deutsch (High Holy Days) 1896
Rev. A. Heilpern, Cantor 1894 – 1897
Rabbi A. J. Messing, Jr. 1897 – 1906
Rabbi B. C. Ehrenreich 1906 – 1921
Rabbi William B. Schwartz 1921 – 1928
Rabbi Benjamin Goldstein 1928 – 1933
Rabbi Eugene Blachschleger 1933 – 1965
Rabbi Nathaniel Zimskind (Interim) 1965
Rabbi David Baylinson 1965 – 1994
Rabbi Glenn Jacob   1994 – 1996
Rabbi Laurence Schlesinger 1996 – 2002
Rabbi Kenneth Segel   2002 – 2007
Rabbi Elliot L. Stevens   2007 – 2017