| L. Marcuson | 1852 | |
| H. Meyer | 1852 | |
| A. Hermann | 1858 | |
| Rev. Joseph Blumenthal | 1858 – 1862 | |
| Rabbi James K. Gutheim | 1863 – 1864 | |
| Rev. M. H. Meyers | 1865 | |
| Rev. G. L. Rosenberger | 1866 – 1869 | |
| Rabbi E. B. M. Browne | 1869 – 1880 | |
| Rabbi Adolph Moses | 1870 – 1873 | |
| Rabbi B. E. Jacobs | 1873 – 1876 | |
| Rabbi Sigmund Hecht | 1876 – 1888 | |
| Rabbi E. K. Fischer | 1888 – 1892 | |
| Rabbi David Davidson | 1892 – 1895 | |
| Rabbi Israel Joseph | 1895 – 1896 | |
| Prof. Gotthard Deutsch (High Holy Days) | 1896 | |
| Rev. A. Heilpern, Cantor | 1894 – 1897 | |
| Rabbi A. J. Messing, Jr. | 1897 – 1906 | |
| Rabbi B. C. Ehrenreich | 1906 – 1921 | |
| Rabbi William B. Schwartz | 1921 – 1928 | |
| Rabbi Benjamin Goldstein | 1928 – 1933 | |
| Rabbi Eugene Blachschleger | 1933 – 1965 | |
| Rabbi Nathaniel Zimskind (Interim) | 1965 | |
| Rabbi David Baylinson | 1965 – 1994 | |
| Rabbi Glenn Jacob | 1994 – 1996 | |
| Rabbi Laurence Schlesinger | 1996 – 2002 | |
| Rabbi Kenneth Segel | 2002 – 2007 | |
| Rabbi Elliot L. Stevens | 2007 – 2017 |
